I had back-to-back pizza this weekend. Both places I visited have been the subject of lots of commentary in magazines and newspapers and on food blogs. I was excited to try both first hand.
First up was Franny’s. I got off to a good start - a gin martini made with a house-pickled golden beet. And, although this place is known for its pies andfor its commitment to sustainable agriculture, it is the commitment to making salumi in house that really excites me. So, we started with pork cheek and beef tongue terrine, which was silky and sweet and glistening and exactly the snack I want to eat on a cold night. We moved onto wood-roasted octopus served with lemony olive-flecked creaminess, and leeks with capers and raisins. (The octo was divine, the leeks tasted wonderful but would have benefited from being either 1) braised further and so more tender or 2) cut into fork-friendly rings.)
We ordered the pie with clams, chilies and parsley. Usually I like to go with a simple tomato and mozz pie for a first outing, but I had heard raves about the clam and really wanted to try it, especially after seeing it at our neighbor’s table. The sweet, creamy, lightly briny, fresh quality of the topping was heavenly. I would have been thrilled to have a bowl of topping with a side of bread, but as it was, the crust was so-so. It tasted great: smoky, charred on the edges, but it was sort of soggy - the point of the triangle of a slice had no spine at all. Don’t get me wrong - I’ll return to Franny’s. It was a glowingly lovely meal and there are many other house-cured meats to sample.
The next night I went to Una Pizza Napoletana. The chef-owner is a man possessed by a desire to produce only perfect pies. He has a bad-ass wood burning oven, makes each pie himself, doesn’t allow any changes to the short, elegant menu, makes a bunch of dough each morning and closes up shop when the dough is gone. He’s got the zeal of a missionary; although he doesn’t want you to stop eating American style pizza, he wants you to stop calling it pizza, and to recognize his classic Neopolitan style as the One True Way. He charges a remarkable $21 for a pie. His feeling is that we should be paying twice that much for the amount of love he puts into it.
We had a marinara pie (San Marzano tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, oregano, garlic, basil, and sea salt) and a filetti (cherry tomatoes, buffalo mozzarella, garlic, extra virgin olive oil, basil, and sea salt). The marinara was tasty for sure but the filleti was far and away the winner. The sweet tang of the cherry tomatoes, the mild creaminess of the cheese, the high note of salt, the yeast of the bread all came together in a transporting sigh - you are taken somewhere where the sun is warm. I learned recently that wine is not the traditional Italian choice of beverage for pizza, that they believe that beer or carbonated cola go much better - and really loved washing it down with a Peroni. But again, a little too much softness in the center of the dough disk. I understand that DOC pies in Naples are eaten with a knife and fork and that some tenderness is the ideal, but both pies verged on soggy.
Both of Franny’s and Una Pizza were very good restaurants with thoughtfully chosen ingredients and a great deal of demonstrated care and traditional ovens. And their pizzas are better than much of what you can get even at New York’s other top-rated pizza joints. But neither sent me into full-blown pizza reveries. Maybe it was an off night for each. And it isn’t that I want a stiff crunch through the whole pie - I’m ok with some yield in the center. But soupy and moist, after so much ink has been spilled about their wood-fired superiority, was a tiny bit of a let down.
Perhaps they - or I - suffered from heightened expectations. Is it possible that all of the voices in print and putting forward opinions online have undermined my ability to experience pizza for what it is, rather than for how it compares to everything else and everyone else’s experience? What a weird shame, if so. And a bit of a catch - how, for example, would I know I want to make a New Haven pilgrimage if not for the pizza-obsessed writers I read? With so much pizza choice in these five boroughs alone, how else would I know where to begin?