…but doubtless God never did.”
I love raspberries best because they are the most consistently wonderful berry, and I have tremendous nostalgia for blueberries from living in Vermont and teaching myself how to make preserves, but nothing beats strawberries during the five minutes that they are perfect. For regular consumers buying locally in USDA Hardiness Zone 6B, that moment has passed for this year. On to stone fruits.
But the pastry chef at Eleven Madison was able to procure some lovely strawberries, and was determined to improve on God’s handiwork, through her “Variations on Greenmarket Strawberries”.
As my pastry mod written assignment I have been asked to taste and describe a plated dessert. My initial plan had been to head down to Room 4 Dessert to check out some of Will Goldfarb’s sweets-as-science, but it is closed indefinitely. So MK and I agreed to scratch our shared itch to eat at Eleven Madison, a joint I can otherwise ill afford, to have some sugary afterschool snacks.

The plate I received consisted of:
Strawberry sorbet sprinkled with crushed strawberry meringue. The sorbet was fairly standard - creamy texture, fairly straightforward berry flavor, bluish pink color, cheery little 2″ quenelle sitting on the upper right of the plate. The crumbly bits of baby pink cookie sprinkled on top had an elderflower flavor and a traditional airy crunch.
Strawberry “spaghetti”, fine pulpy strands made from juice and agar-agar. This greyish pink mush was the least successful (if the most inventive) part of the plate. It tasted of an undersugared fruit rollup and looked like a pile of defeated fruit, with no discernible spaghetti-like strands. It sat in the center of the plate.
Strawberry foam studded with small cubes of lychee. It was viscous. The lychee was tasty.
Lychee gelee embedded with a strawberry slice, looking like a Victorian momento, something you’d find in grandma’s jewelry box.
Two tiny, perfect frais de bois. Maybe they were just unusually luscious regular berries on the super-teeny, extra-fragrant side.
Onto this was poured an elderflower and lychee broth. A small plate of chewy, buttery, chili-spiked financier cookies were perfect for sopping up this broth once it had been thickened with melted sorbet, foam, etc.
In contrast to this intellectual exercise on the strawberry, MK received the Peach Souffle, which came in a tidy package, arguably undernourished peach-wise, but still simply delicious and accompanied by a dollop of heavenly lemon thyme ice cream.
So my judgement is this: a well-executed basic beats elaborate gussying. My dessert gave me far more to talk about, but hers lingers in my taste memory, and that is confers a much greater value.